Files
natural-memory-nm21/router_verdict_final.md
T
WpyQwq 643e22ecb9 Natural Memory NM2.1: 记忆路由器分叉、数据集缺陷修复与全轴评测证据
- 引入 MemoryRouterXL 与 v5/v6 流式多线程训练/编码管线
- 修复 prepare_memory_router_dataset 候选池重建缺陷(mega 家族 3568x 加速,输出逐字节相同)
- 修复 v5 被破坏的拒答与多跳标签(train 未知样本 319 -> 16319,multi_hop 平均正例 1.00 -> 2.00)
- 同存储预算下 V2-128 v6 逐轴 22/22 通过:Top-1 41.12% -> 94.62%,未知拒答 0.00% -> 100.00%
- 记录三条被实测推翻的显然优化(logits_to_keep=1 反而慢 55%、XL 容量未带来收益)
- 记忆手术跨架构可移植性 14/14,读写关闭时与原生模型逐位相同
2026-09-19 11:11:31 +08:00

10 KiB

指标 最强旧基线 基线值 候选值 差值 判定
Top-1 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 41.12% 94.37% +53.24pp 通过
Top-1 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 41.12% 94.14% +53.01pp 通过
Top-1 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 41.12% 94.18% +53.06pp 通过
Top-1 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 41.12% 95.02% +53.90pp 通过
Top-1 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 41.12% 95.19% +54.06pp 通过
Recall@1 V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.03% 88.82% +51.79pp 通过
Recall@1 V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.03% 88.58% +51.55pp 通过
Recall@1 V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.03% 88.65% +51.62pp 通过
Recall@1 V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.03% 89.48% +52.46pp 通过
Recall@1 V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.03% 89.64% +52.61pp 通过
Recall@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 46.73% 96.40% +49.67pp 通过
Recall@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 46.73% 96.48% +49.75pp 通过
Recall@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 46.73% 96.66% +49.93pp 通过
Recall@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 46.73% 96.53% +49.80pp 通过
Recall@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 46.73% 97.45% +50.72pp 通过
Recall@5 V2-128 deployed(v3) 48.91% 97.40% +48.48pp 通过
Recall@5 V2-128 deployed(v3) 48.91% 97.15% +48.23pp 通过
Recall@5 V2-128 deployed(v3) 48.91% 97.64% +48.73pp 通过
Recall@5 V2-128 deployed(v3) 48.91% 97.61% +48.69pp 通过
Recall@5 V2-128 deployed(v3) 48.91% 98.20% +49.29pp 通过
MRR V2-128 deployed(v3) 47.69% 95.97% +48.28pp 通过
MRR V2-128 deployed(v3) 47.69% 95.77% +48.08pp 通过
MRR V2-128 deployed(v3) 47.69% 95.87% +48.18pp 通过
MRR V2-128 deployed(v3) 47.69% 96.64% +48.95pp 通过
MRR V2-128 deployed(v3) 47.69% 96.70% +49.01pp 通过
nDCG@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 44.22% 95.31% +51.09pp 通过
nDCG@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 44.22% 95.37% +51.15pp 通过
nDCG@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 44.22% 95.48% +51.26pp 通过
nDCG@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 44.22% 95.60% +51.38pp 通过
nDCG@3 V2-128 deployed(v3) 44.22% 96.43% +52.21pp 通过
多跳证据全中(Top-3) V2-128 deployed(v3) 43.43% 95.95% +52.53pp 通过
多跳证据全中(Top-3) V2-128 deployed(v3) 43.43% 96.22% +52.80pp 通过
多跳证据全中(Top-3) V2-128 deployed(v3) 43.43% 96.44% +53.01pp 通过
多跳证据全中(Top-3) V2-128 deployed(v3) 43.43% 95.35% +51.92pp 通过
多跳证据全中(Top-3) V2-128 deployed(v3) 43.43% 97.29% +53.86pp 通过
多跳证据全中(仅多正例) V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.15% 92.10% +54.95pp 通过
多跳证据全中(仅多正例) V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.15% 95.45% +58.30pp 通过
多跳证据全中(仅多正例) V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.15% 96.05% +58.90pp 通过
多跳证据全中(仅多正例) V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.15% 78.85% +41.70pp 通过
多跳证据全中(仅多正例) V2-128 deployed(v3) 37.15% 97.05% +59.90pp 通过
hop 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 73.23% 100.00% +26.77pp 通过
hop 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 73.23% 100.00% +26.77pp 通过
hop 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 73.23% 100.00% +26.77pp 通过
hop 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 73.23% 100.00% +26.77pp 通过
hop 正确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 73.23% 100.00% +26.77pp 通过
hop 欠预测率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 4.68% 0.00% -4.68pp 通过
hop 欠预测率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 4.68% 0.00% -4.68pp 通过
hop 欠预测率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 4.68% 0.00% -4.68pp 通过
hop 欠预测率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 4.68% 0.00% -4.68pp 通过
hop 欠预测率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 4.68% 0.00% -4.68pp 通过
need F1 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 89.58% 100.00% +10.42pp 通过
need F1 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 89.58% 100.00% +10.42pp 通过
need F1 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 89.58% 100.00% +10.42pp 通过
need F1 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 89.58% 100.00% +10.42pp 通过
need F1 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 89.58% 100.00% +10.42pp 通过
need 召回 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 99.82% 100.00% +0.18pp 通过
need 召回 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 99.82% 100.00% +0.18pp 通过
need 召回 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 99.82% 100.00% +0.18pp 通过
need 召回 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 99.82% 100.00% +0.18pp 通过
need 召回 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 99.82% 100.00% +0.18pp 通过
未知拒答率 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.00% 100.00% +100.00pp 通过
未知拒答率 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.00% 100.00% +100.00pp 通过
未知拒答率 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.00% 100.00% +100.00pp 通过
未知拒答率 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.00% 100.00% +100.00pp 通过
未知拒答率 (门槛 0.50) V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.00% 100.00% +100.00pp 通过
已知问题被误拒率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.18% 0.00% -0.18pp 通过
已知问题被误拒率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.18% 0.00% -0.18pp 通过
已知问题被误拒率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.18% 0.00% -0.18pp 通过
已知问题被误拒率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.18% 0.00% -0.18pp 通过
已知问题被误拒率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 0.18% 0.00% -0.18pp 通过
未知问题被误读率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 100.00% 0.00% -100.00pp 通过
未知问题被误读率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 100.00% 0.00% -100.00pp 通过
未知问题被误读率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 100.00% 0.00% -100.00pp 通过
未知问题被误读率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 100.00% 0.00% -100.00pp 通过
未知问题被误读率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 100.00% 0.00% -100.00pp 通过
仲裁准确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 81.12% 100.00% +18.88pp 通过
仲裁准确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 81.12% 100.00% +18.88pp 通过
仲裁准确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 81.12% 100.00% +18.88pp 通过
仲裁准确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 81.12% 100.00% +18.88pp 通过
仲裁准确率 V2-128 deployed(v3) 81.12% 100.00% +18.88pp 通过
平均分数余量 V2-128 deployed(v3) -9.2989 51.3153 +60.6143 通过
平均分数余量 V2-128 deployed(v3) -9.2989 40.1456 +49.4445 通过
平均分数余量 V2-128 deployed(v3) -9.2989 73.2482 +82.5471 通过
平均分数余量 V2-128 deployed(v3) -9.2989 215.7533 +225.0522 通过
平均分数余量 V2-128 deployed(v3) -9.2989 200.3346 +209.6335 通过
单查询延迟 ms (GPU) V2-128 deployed(v3) 1.0995 0.9277 -0.1718 通过
单查询延迟 ms (GPU) V2-128 deployed(v3) 1.0995 0.9663 -0.1332 通过
单查询延迟 ms (GPU) V2-128 deployed(v3) 1.0995 0.9488 -0.1507 通过
单查询延迟 ms (GPU) V2-128 deployed(v3) 1.0995 1.4501 +0.3505 未通过
单查询延迟 ms (GPU) V2-128 deployed(v3) 1.0995 1.5358 +0.4363 未通过
路由 QPS (GPU, 单查询) V2-128 deployed(v3) 909.4856 1077.8859 +168.4003 通过
路由 QPS (GPU, 单查询) V2-128 deployed(v3) 909.4856 1034.8360 +125.3505 通过
路由 QPS (GPU, 单查询) V2-128 deployed(v3) 909.4856 1053.9133 +144.4277 通过
路由 QPS (GPU, 单查询) V2-128 deployed(v3) 909.4856 689.6254 -219.8602 未通过
路由 QPS (GPU, 单查询) V2-128 deployed(v3) 909.4856 651.1112 -258.3744 未通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=64) V2-128 deployed(v3) 66037.9306 72856.4274 +6818.4967 通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=64) V2-128 deployed(v3) 66037.9306 69378.1979 +3340.2673 通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=64) V2-128 deployed(v3) 66037.9306 71586.7654 +5548.8348 通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=64) V2-128 deployed(v3) 66037.9306 46891.9434 -19145.9872 未通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=64) V2-128 deployed(v3) 66037.9306 33111.5549 -32926.3757 未通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256) V2-128 deployed(v3) 207287.4493 236293.1512 +29005.7019 通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256) V2-128 deployed(v3) 207287.4493 242759.8763 +35472.4270 通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256) V2-128 deployed(v3) 207287.4493 177958.2077 -29329.2416 未通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256) V2-128 deployed(v3) 207287.4493 85734.5711 -121552.8782 未通过
批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256) V2-128 deployed(v3) 207287.4493 131545.1415 -75742.3078 未通过
地址字节/记录 V2-128 deployed(v3) 512.0000 512.0000 +0.0000 通过
地址字节/记录 V2-128 deployed(v3) 512.0000 512.0000 +0.0000 通过
地址字节/记录 V2-128 deployed(v3) 512.0000 2048.0000 +1536.0000 未通过
地址字节/记录 V2-128 deployed(v3) 512.0000 2048.0000 +1536.0000 未通过
地址字节/记录 V2-128 deployed(v3) 512.0000 512.0000 +0.0000 通过

逐候选判定(全方位超越是对单个路由器说的)

路由器 通过 未通过 全方位超越 未通过的轴
V2-128 v6 final 22 0 是 -
REPLAY-128 v7 final 22 0 是 -
V2-512 v6 final 20 2 否 批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256), 地址字节/记录
XL-512 v6 final 17 5 否 单查询延迟 ms (GPU), 路由 QPS (GPU, 单查询), 批量 QPS (GPU, batch=64), 批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256), 地址字节/记录
XL-128 v6 final 18 4 否 单查询延迟 ms (GPU), 路由 QPS (GPU, 单查询), 批量 QPS (GPU, batch=64), 批量 QPS (GPU, batch=256)

汇总 99 项通过 / 11 项未通过 / 0 项无数据